One of the most significant contributions stemming from the "Decade of the Brain" period is the increasing recognition that when it comes to human development, it is skills and not abilities that truly matter. Indeed, much of what once was passed off as 'abilities' are now replaced by 'skills'. Perhaps it is time to dethrone the outmoded subject 'Mental Abilities' that one still comes across in certain Scholastic Aptitude Tests in schools. These, even in the era of Multiple Intelligences, carry the outdated baggage of IQ that, as one of my friends who served in the Curriculum Development of some of the National Level Tests, says, were after all meant to eliminate certain classes of peoples from gaining opportunities. reserved for a certain Elite. Granted, MI is as yet not in a fully applicable stage and attempting to do so prematurely does ill other than flaunting its name and terminology so as to give a modernist flavor. Thus one sees a host of MI schools and institutions, the only qualification of whose teachers is to pay lip-service to all that is MI, or rather, Something-Smart, people-smart, language-smart, etc. It would be better to use plain common sense in stimulating the cognitive faculties by evoking the innate sense of curiosity, surprise, awe, wonder and mystery in the student and instill an a habit of life-long learning.
Daniel Coyle's book "The Talent Code" has as its subtitle, "Greatness isn't Born, It's Grown". It is a powerful tour de force marshaling evidence in favour of Nurture in the unending Nature vs Nurture debate. He begins the book with essentially three questions:
- How does a penniless Russian tennis club with one indoor court create more top-twenty women players than the entire United States?
- How does a humble storefront music school in Dallas, Texas, produce Jessica Simpson, Demi Lovato, and a succession of pop music phenoms?
- How does a poor, scantily educated British family in a remote village turn out three world-class writers?
The rest of the book delves on this theme and marshals evidence that demonstrates that talent is a result of deliberate practice. This reminds me of another book, by Geoff Colvin, "Talent is Overrated"
that we can visit some other time. Deliberate practice, or Deep Practice as Coyle terms it, is then the key to Great Performance and that, in turn rests on something unexpected, making mistakes. This should not come as a surprise when we appreciate the fact, that it is the very device that Nature uses for evolution. Without errors, we would be prokaryotes, or bacteria yet. Every cell has an error-prone and an error-correcting mechanism. A fine balance exists between the two. As long as the balance exists, that is, in absence of mutation, the species is preserved intact. When the balance tips in the favor of error due to its accumulation over a long period of time, and across populations of organisms, however, mutation occurs. Thus Nature practices Deep Practice to evolve species. And human beings would disdain Nature's wisdom in claiming some special knowledge,- the knowledge that mysteriously enables them to judge other human beings as intelligent or stupid. Daniel Coyle's book dispels this spacious ignorance.
No comments:
Post a Comment